Whey is the Way! (Protein powder redux)
With apologies to all you pasty-skinned, calcium-deficient vegans out there ("I keed, I keed!"):
Drops of nectar from the Vaisnava Body Building Group on Facebook.
Whey protein, made from cow's milk, is the best source of protein for the human body, according to present nutritional and sports science.
Whey protein powder (isolate and concentrate) is a byproduct of cheese production. Milk is separated into curds and whey using rennet. The whey is then dried under a low temperature and turned to a powder.
Ajita Krsna points out that the rennet used in commercial cheese production is commonly made by killing small calves, then grinding up their fourth stomach. Cheese made using this rennet is not considered offerable or consumable by devotees. Instead, those devotees who do use commercial cheeses look for ones made using "vegetarian rennet", typically chemical or microbial in origin.
There are no "vegetarian" whey powders, but what we're looking for here is a "kosher whey powder" (any Jewish body builders in the house?). According to kosher dietary laws meat and milk cannot be mixed, so kosher milk products are also "Vaisnava bonafide".
US Premium whey protein isolate turns out to fit the bill. It's available in Australia, free postage, and costs only $38/kg for an order of 4kg. That's very economical. At my local organics store whey protein isolate is $54/kg in the bulk bin, and GNC, etc. carry branded protein powders for $60+ for 750g.
Manigriva, from Melbourne, pointed out Nutiva Hemp Protein Powder.

That's one for all you vegans out there, and it's also got some serious counter-cultural cred (check out The Hemp Revolution on Google Video). It has 37% protein (compared to whey protein isolate's 93%), and the bioavailability of that protein is lower than that of whey, but it's hemp man! Green all the way through.
A number of people have asked me about the "Vedic Mass" protein powder that features as the picture for the Vaisnava Bodybuilding Group. No, I didn't photoshop it. It's real. I found it by googling "Vedic Bodybuilding" as an image search.

It's made by Vedic Biolabs, in Bangalore, India. They also make "Vedic Proteen", which is a protein powder with added Ayurvedic goodness (Brahmi, Ashwagandha and Shankapushpi), and "Vedic Fat CHQ" to control weight. There are no "get immediate results from your first set within 15 minutes of taking this" claims here, it's all-Ayurvedic rasa: "Vedic Mass Builder has to be consumed for a minimum period of 3 months to get the desired results. Results vary from person to person.".
OK...
At the other end of the spectrum, here's the profile picture for an Australian body building group on Facebook.

Now that's taking it a little too far...
- sitapati's blog
- Login or register to post comments




thanks admin....
thanks admin....
Concerns?
Are there any kidney or liver function concerns associated with taking whey protien supplements?
Whey Facts
Whey proteins primarily consist of α-lactalbumin and β-lactoglobulin. Depending on the method of manufacture and may also contain glycomacropeptides. These are often used as nutritional supplement specially for bodybuilders. And If you wish to have an increase in Body Mass, Whey is the way to do it.
Whey Facts
Whey proteins primarily consist of α-lactalbumin and β-lactoglobulin. Depending on the method of manufacture and may also contain glycomacropeptides. These are often used as nutritional supplement specially for bodybuilders. And If you wish to have an increase in Body Mass, Whey is the way to do it.
Pro- and Anti-Whey Protein
Anti- Whey Protein supplementation:
http://www.diseaseproof.com/archives/hurtful-food-how-safe-are-protein-drinks-and-powders.html
Summary:
* High protein diet contributes to renal (kidney) failure
* High protein diet causes osteoporosis, as the acidic protein requires buffering, and your body leaches calcium from your bones to do it
Pro- Whey Protein Supplementation:
http://www.bodybuildingforyou.com/protein/protein-nutrition-myth-2.htm
Summary:
* Evidence of renal failure is only from studies involving subjects with pre-existing kidney problems (see here for study information that supports this)
* Leaching and Osteoporosis can be avoided by balancing the body's pH using other factors.
A rough guide is that you should take 1-1.25g of protein per lb of bodyweight (multiply your kg weight by 2.2). You should do physical exercise to utilize it, and you should be careful to keep your pH balanced. I'll write another article about pH balancing.
Thanks for that - I look
Thanks for that - I look forward to the pH article
Kosher
Haribol I would like to clarify a point about this statement, ". According to kosher dietary laws meat and milk cannot be mixed, so kosher milk products are also "Vaisnava bonafide""
Once I had a devotee debate with me that his yogurt was veggie because it contained kosher gelatin. He was thinking that kosher gelatin means kosher yogurt.
This however is not true. It was beef based kosher gelatin. (as the company told me over the phone) Cow meat that was blessed by a Rabbi, the yogurt would not be considered kosher with this ingredient, just the gelatin was kosher.
Hare KRishna!
:)
ys
Nityananda Chandra Das
Devadeva posted a link to
Devadeva posted a link to her facebook page that further complicates the situation:
The Dairy Down Low
We do need our own term like kosher to describe our dietary restrictions (as I previously argued here). "Vaisnava Bonafide" whey protein powder is what we're after here. It should come from Herd Share or otherwise protected cows, and use non-animal rennet.
Kosher is still the best bet though, as the post goes on to say:
Ew. You know how we believe
Ew. You know how we believe that we're not our bodies... well, I'm pretty sure that guy actually *is* his body. And that's pretty much it. Creeeeeeeeepy.
Heh - of course, I'd say
Heh - of course, I'd say that we *understand* that we are not this body, but rather that we have a body. As for the picture, yeah, that looks unhealthy, and I don't mean just physically.
Kosher Whey
The whey protein powder we have here in Australia is kosher and halal approved. However it is from NZ and Australia.
Check out our new Professional Whey Blog for the health differences between WPI and WPC.
Stephen
Professional Whey
Hi
Hey if you also have problem on your kidney you can prevent it. But best will be to talk to your doctor before trying it. kidney stone treatment
its realy good
Thanks, for the good articles ...I am very intiresting..