Much love to Madhava Gosh

Madhava Gosh's piece on annotations got taken to pieces by Pandu [1 and 2] when it appeared on Dandavats.com in the context of the resolution 311 conversation.

Gosh prabhu starts off his piece by admitting that he hasn't even read the resolution under discussion, so it wasn't hard for Pandu to go from there and take it apart. Gosh caught me with my pants down though, after I commented on his piece when it originally appeared on his blog - without reading it myself. hahahaha, ironic eh? :-)

Luckily Gosh is a liberal Vaisnava and gave me the benefit of the doubt:

Perhaps you were speed reading and assumed...

If he'd been a conservative I might have been in trouble. ;-)

Madhava Gosh prabhu's piece is good for what it is, but a solid philosophical justification or defense of resolution 311 it is not. We're still waiting for something more substantial in that area.